Part of a continuing series on the 2007 Oscar nominations.
Nominated for
- Best Picture
- Best Director - Clint Eastwood
- Best Original Screenplay - Iris Yamashita, Paul Haggis
- Sound Editing - Alan Robert Murray
After Martin Scorsese (but only sometimes), the greatest living American director has to be Clint Eastwood.
Clint Eastwood! The guy who drove a truck with an orangutan is an amazing director!
I've only seen half of his latest achievement (I haven't had a chance to get to
Flags of Our Fathers yet), but this is the kind of story that I've always wanted to write, the story of people that we know are going to end up losing their war, but who have their own hope of going home victorious still. That hope quickly fades as the story unfolds and the characters realize how grim their situation is.
This film is going to be a strong contender for best picture, and if Scorses weren't nominated for best director, I'd see it easily taking that statue as well. It's a shame that none of the actors received nods in the best [supporting] actor categories.
In the screenplay category I see a few big obstacles to this film getting recognition. First up, is the fact that it's in Japanese. That on its own isn't necessarily a problem, but the subtitling was not always as good as it should be, leading to some moments of unintentional humor through the film. As a film with cowriters who speak English and Japanese, there shoudn't be this sort of problem with the subtitles.
Next up is the over-reliance on voice-over narration early in the film. We start out by having the story told through the letters of the soldiers and leaders of the film. This would be a good device for telling the story,
if it were carried out consistently. Unfortunately, the letters disappear almost completely in the second half of the film, having the end result that the use of the device early in the film ends up coming across as clumsiness. The epistolary form is a difficult one to pull off in a movie--
84 Charing Cross Road is the only film I've seen that did it well--and I think that this is a big enough flaw to disqualify the film from winning this category.
NP: Lesson 8,
Pimsleur Basic Czech.
WC: 39,656, ECD: 19 April 2007.